If you’re already a fan of Tony’s, these new menu items might be an even bigger incentive to visit, but they don’t quite deliver “upscale” Italian for us, even if we enjoyed a few of the new menu options. While Tony’s Garlic Bread was a fairly reasonable price of $11, the entree prices and the rushed atmosphere make us hesitant to return. So, would we come back to Tony’s for the new dishes? We’d love to come back just for the garlic bread, but we’re not sure if we’d return just for the other new menu items.

You could instead grab a quick service meal where you can generally sit as long as you like. We felt a little rushed during our meal so this might not be the place to sit and visit. The Shrimp Scampi is $30 and the Penne with Chicken Al Forno is $26, so this isn’t exactly cheap dining. These dishes are basic and the restaurant has proved to be very hit or miss. You might want to try Via Napoli in EPCOT if that’s what you’re looking for. Even with these new menu additions, they might not be what you’d consider “upscale” Italian food. You should SKIP trying Tony’s new menu if… If you are seated on the porch, you can get an excellent view of the Festival of Fantasy Parade or the 50th Anniversary Cavalcade.

You’re looking for a restaurant with good Main Street, U.S.A.

We won’t judge if you join the Walk-Up Waitlist just to try that garlic bread! These new menu items might not be earth-shattering but we did enjoy a few of them! We will say, you can find better Italian dishes in Disney Springs and EPCOT though.

You already enjoy eating at Tony’s Town Square Restaurant and you’re looking for Italian dishes at Magic Kingdom.

You SHOULD try the new items at Tony’s if… It’s still the dairy family at least 😅 /4hXBonqySC We still whole heartedly believe cheese can be dessert 😘🧀īut we’re trying Tony’s Spumoni Tart 🍒 and Mandarincello Custard 🍊

Recommended Disneyland Restaurants for First-Timers.

Recommended Disney World Restaurants for First-Timers.

Disney World Restaurants Menus & Reviews.

Disney World Annual Passholder Discounts.

Tower square pizza menu